Elvie Catch Vs Haakaa Ladybug – Which One Best?

ByWinters Hours Updated:

Do you have trouble deciding between Elvie Catch and Haaka Ladybug? If so, read our post below and make an informed decision!

Overview of Elvie and Haakaa Breast Pumps

The Elvie and the Haakaa are both categorized as manual pumps that rely on soft suction rather than anything motorized or battery-powered. Although many mothers use the Elvie Catch or the Haakaa primarily to gather milk that would typically flow out of the breast opposite the one their kid is feeding on, you may use them to manually pump.

Basically, when you let it down, you have three options: let it soak your shirt, collect it in a pad by putting a burp cloth in your bra, or catch it in one of these manual pumps and start to stockpile breast milk in your freezer (win-win)!

What is Elvie Catch

The Elvie Catch is a wearable silicone breast pump for a simple, hands-free milk collection. It’s shaped like a disc and is easy to use.

Pros for Elvie Catch

  • Soft and comfortable, it’s made from food-grade silicone and is easy to clean.
  • Since every mother should be able to leave the house without worrying about spilling milk, the Elvie Catch includes two non-slip milk collection cups, designed for complete comfort and confidence, even for breastfeeding moms who experience significant milk-heavy leakage.
  • Similar to the breast pump, the Elvie Catch’s design enables you to use it while still in your bra, saving you time and being extremely handy.
  • The Elvie Catch is designed to conform to the natural shape of a woman’s chest and can be worn comfortably for up to three hours. The uniquely shaped silicone discs can be rotated to find the best fit while protecting even the most delicate skin on the chest.
  • The non-slip silicone keeps the Elvie Catch in place and prevents precious milk leakage. Each glass has a capacity of 30ml of milk. No more wasted milk on breast pads.
  • The Elvie Catch has a smooth profile and fits inside the bra so moms can discreetly collect milk flow and get on with their day.
  • The collection cups clean easily by hand or in the dishwasher, so they can be used every day and are safe for both mother and baby.
  • It is hands-free. It fits snugly and pleasantly in your bra (again, due to its form).

Cons of Elvie Catch

  • When transferring additional milk from the Elvie Catch to the storage bag, it’s a little challenging to see the ounces on the silicone container.
  • When you’re on a breastfeeding journey. It’s more difficult to tell how much milk you have because the silicone container is covered in an opaque material.
  • Elvie Catch is more pricey.

What is Haakaa Ladybug?

The Haakaa silicone milk collector allows you to express milk using the power of natural suction or gentle suction! It just fastens to the breast and lets milk naturally flow out. Haakaa is the ideal tool for every mom because it is small, portable, and lightweight. Use it anywhere, including on long journeys and car rides. Connect to the side breast during a nursing session to capture any letdown that could otherwise be lost on a nursing pad.

Pros for Haakaa

  • Haakaa is a supple, comfy breast pump made entirely of premium, food-grade silicone. Free of BPA, PVC, and phthalates.
  • The Milk Collector is perfectly portable and includes little feet on the bottom that allow it to stand upright on level surfaces to stop spillage after usage.
  • Instead of soaking up leaking and letdown with breast pads, save every drop. Put it inside the nursing bra and push it on your breast. Breast milk leaks are delicately collected by the ladybug.
  • You can simply determine how much extra milk you have gathered at any time when pumping and whether or not you need to apply additional suction.
  • It’s simple to read the side of the Haakaa after you’ve finished pumping. Allowing you to precisely identify your storage bag with the amount of milk you gathered.
  • Compared to Elvie Catch, Haakaa is quite inexpensive.

Cons for Haakaa

  • The Haakaa is fantastic when you’re alone at home and away from other people. But because of its form and the way it fastens to your breast, it’s rather difficult to use while you’re out and about or in front of other people unless you want to be entirely nude on top. There are definitely some women who are at ease with that, but not all of them.
  • The Haakaa’s major drawback is that you have to watch it while it is on your breast.
  • It’s really simple for the Haakaa to come off when your baby becomes older and starts to move about, kick, etc. when feeding.

Where do Haakaa Ladybug And Elvie Catch Tie?

There are a few aspects that, in my opinion, apply to these two pumps equally yet differently.

  • Despite the stark differences in design between the two pumps, moving the milk supply from the pump to the feeding bottle or storage container, once you’re through pumping, is really simple.
  • Both the Elvie Catch and the Haakaa seem like they are only one toddler visit away from spilling that priceless liquid gold. Despite having a flat bottom to place on a table. (To assist prevent this, you may purchase a stopper or cover for the Haakaa.)
  • Elvie Catch and Haakaa are both composed of pliable, dishwasher-safe silicone that is food-grade.
  • You might need to use two hands to position and attach both pumps precisely, and one hand to apply extra suction.

Elvie Catch Vs. Haakaa — Which One Is Better?

Both Elvie Catch and Haakaa, in my opinion, are fantastic products, and anyone would make you pleased. The Elvie Catch, as opposed to the Haakaa, is the manual pump I would choose if I had to pay money for one.

The Elvie Catch is a hands-free, covert, efficient, and stable gadget. Along with sharing my selection with you, I have previously covered all the pertinent information on the two pumps. Allowing you to make your own decision.